All we hear is...short-selling brouhaha
With the Indian markets having a spectacular meltdown over the last few days (Nifty down 13% over the past five days), there are calls on the government to intervene. This intervention is sought in the form of either the government shutting down the stock markets, or at least banning short selling. Neither proposal finds favour with this author due to the inherent weakness of this approach. Market is simply a mechanism of price discovery. It is well known that it acts as a voting machine in the near term, and a weighing machine in the long term. Greed & fear responses of investors find expression in near term stock price movements. The risks of investing in equity is also well known to its participants. As such, shutting down the market due to adverse price conditions, or banning short selling run actually contra to the ethos of investing. While it is true that shutting down the market will freeze stock prices at a higher level, this would not be price discovery. Also, wh...